| Class of 2020 |
| Idris Carter | OF | Roosevelt | 2020 | SUNY Stony Brook | Division 1 | American East |
| Class of 2019 |
| Jason Barry | RHP | Hewlett | 2019 | SUNY Old Westbury (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Antonio Egidio | 1B | Hewlett | 2019 | SUNY Cobleskill (NY) | Division 3 | NEAC |
| Oscar Fajardo | 1B | Brentwood | 2019 | SUNY Old Westbury (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Trent Mayer | 1B/3B | Northport | 2019 | Keene State (NH) | Division 3 | Little Neck |
| Jamal Ritter | OF | Valley Stream Central | 2019 | SUNY Old Westbury (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Class of 2018 |
| Thomas Consiglio | RHP | Kellenberg | 2018 | Fairleigh Dickinson (NJ) | Division 3 | MAC |
| Shane Mugnolo | RHP/SS | Xaverian | 2018 | Cortland State (NY) | Division 3 | SUNYAC |
| Thomas Nacchia | OF | Deer Park | 2018 | SUNY Maritime (NY | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Class of 2017 |
| Billy Amendola | RHP | Northport | 2017 | SUNY Old Westbury (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Domenick Castiglione | RHP | Fort Hamilton | 2017 | College of Staten Island (NY) | Division 3 | CUNY |
| Kevin Dunn | RHP | Long Beach | 2017 | SUNY Maritime (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Jake Ford | OF | Denton | 2017 | Suffolk CC (NY | Division 3 | Region 15 |
| Sean Klein | RHP | Massapequa | 2017 | Mitchell College (CT) | Division 3 | NECC |
| Anthony Lambroia | C | Commack | 2017 | University of Scranton (PA) | Division 3 | Landmark |
| Jake McCarthy | 3B | Northport | 2017 | Molloy College (NY) | Division 2 | ECC |
| Michael Mirando | 1B/RHP | Islip | 2017 | Hofstra University (NY) | Division 1 | CAA |
| Vincent Pepitone | 2B | Ward Melville | 2017 | SUNY Old Westbury (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Jarrett Rizza | RHP | Home-Schooled | 2017 | Manhattanville College (NY) | Division 3 | MAC |
| Frank Stola | OF | Northport | 2017 | Williams College (MA) | Division 3 | NESCAC |
| George Sutherland | MIF | Northport | 2017 | Cochise College (AZ) | Division 1 | Region 1 |
| Michael Zamora | SS | Xavier | 2017 | Cochise College (AZ) | Division 1 | Region 1 |
| Class of 2016 |
| Paul Dominguez | RHP | Rocky Point | 2016 | Lynn University (FL) | Division 2 | Sunshine State |
| Skylar Graff | 2B/RHP | Syosset | 2016 | SUNY Maritime (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Brian Herrmann | RHP | Northport | 2016 | Stony Brook University (NY) | Division 1 | American East |
| Tom Neary | 1B | Northport | 2016 | Pace University (NY) | Division 2 | NE10 |
| Nick Palmerini | RHP | Northport | 2016 | SUNY Purchase (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Anthony Sirianni | C | Sayville | 2016 | SUNY Farmingdale (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Joe Stockman | SS | Northport | 2016 | Clarkson University (NY) | Division 3 | Liberty League |
| Kyle Strovink | C | Rocky Point | 2016 | Limestone College (SC) | Division 2 | Conference Carolinas |
| Mike Traynor | LHP | Smithtown West | 2016 | SUNY Maritime (NY) | Division 3 | Skyline |
| Jimmy Valenti | 3B/SS | Massapequa | 2016 | Westfield State (MA) | Division 3 | MASCAC |
